David D replied:
"MLS will unfortunately not ever be even with the Premier Leagues. I would love for that to happen, as a soccer fan. However, Americans do not care. They are a bandwagon country, and only pay attention when they are playing in the World Cup, or another big tournament, and as soon as they lose, they turn off their sets."
eric cartman replied:
"1 more big signing like beckham"
Anto.G replied:
"It will never happen. The MLS is the equivalent of the English second tier, the Championship, only at the bottom end of the Championship. They have internationals and have some good players sure. But It's not nationally popular and some of the defending is almost schoolboy level. Sorry, but your being far to optimistic."
rockabilly philip paul replied:
"The european leagues have such a history that you are always going to have American players looking to europe. Take someone like Charlie Davies, I'm sure he could have signed with the MLS had he chose to. He was the number #1 player in the country at the university level, but he chose to sign with Hammarby IF. Recent Swedish champions yes but not a major power house. The lore of europe is strong. It's kinda like the old saying " join the army and see the world ". A player can grow both as an athelete and as a person by comming over to europe. And seriously, if you hadto chose between Columbus Ohio and Stockholm Sweden, the Venice of the North, where would you want to play ?In terms of the level of play in the MLS. There is a core group of people on this forum who are NEVER gonna give the MLS any credit, and perhaps getting to the level of the EPL is going to be a long time comming. However the MLS is far from being "crap". A few examples, Peter Philipakos was a star player for Olympicos. Played with them in the Champion League. Was selected to both the US National team and the Greek National team ( his parents are of greek origin ). This is the same Greek team that went on to win the European cup. Last year he tried out for the RedBulls and did not make the cut. Recently the LA Galaxy held an open try out. I think something like 1000 players were looked at. Only two were called back for a second look. One guy had played in the English Championship league and the other had played in Portugal's Liga. Neither made the team. Joe Zewe a star striker in Denmark didn't make the Chicago Fire roster this spring either.Realistically I think the MLS is about at the level of the Dutch League or the English Championship League right now and getting better."
Frederick S replied:
"Right now, I believe MLS is on par with the English Championship (one tier below the EPL). The best MLS clubs like DC United or the New England Revolution would be a notch below the top Scottish Premier League clubs like Celtic and Rangers. They would regularly not make the group stage of the Champions League, getting eliminated in the 2nd or 3rd qualifying round...Is MLS improving? Absolutely... I think in 10-15 years, MLS could be on par with the German Bundesliga and French Ligue One. But I don't think it will be on par with EPL, La Liga or Serie A. These three leagues have so much history, tradition, and huge TV contracts to buy the best players. The Bundesliga and Ligue One have had financial problems in the last few years. I heard most Ligue One clubs lose money each year, and really depend on getting money from transfers. I kind of believe you will see most of the clubs in these two leagues start to cut costs to be financially viable.MLS needs to keep the momentum going. It has a whole bunch of futbol fans in the USA who love European and Mexican leagues but can't stand watching MLS... If it can break into this niche, I believe the casual viewers will also increase. Right now, European clubs are increasing their exposure in the USA which can hurt MLS if they don't continue to improve.This is the best time for MLS to push forward. With all the other sports dealing with major scandals (steroids, corrupt referees, dogfighting), MLS can direct more attention to itself.I also don't think we should judge how "good" MLS is compared to other leagues by who's playing in the league. There are some excellent players in MLS who played in the English Championship but never in EPL. Others who can't make it in Europe but do well in MLS. Then there are players who are famous in Europe but can't make the starting eleven in MLS. It's a matter of fitting in the system with a MLS club. MLS is an athletic and physical league, but not very organized or technically skilled. So a player who's really slow and hates contact but technically gifted might not do very well in MLS, especially if the club doesn't hide his weaknesses. But maybe he's star in La Liga or South America."
hammer replied:
"Probably when the pilgrims come back to England and start all over again. Seriously though, America just doesn't have the passion for the game and any really good American players will go to Europe because that's where the money is. There is no wage cap. Why do you think American business men are buying English football teams and not MLS teams? They know where they can make money, thats why."
us_fulham_fan replied:
"It will only happen when major players turn down EPL, La Liga, Bundesliga, Serie A for equal or more money from an MLS team. It's players salaries that will be the driving factor. Maybe in 20 years it might be there, maybe."
Viva Man Utd replied:
"sh!t when they sign players like Ronaldo, Ronaldinho, Luca Toni, Fernando Torres, Wayne Ronney, Giovanni Dos Santos, and more great players. but it might take about 15 or 20 years cause im from the states and trust me, not much people like soccer only the latinos."